Impeachment no STF é como provocar expulsão de jogador, diz Barroso

O presidente do Supremo Tribunal Federal, Luís Roberto Barroso, disse ser contrário à possibilidade de impeachment de ministros da corte. Em entrevista à CNN, Barroso comparou pedidos nesse sentido a um jogo de futebol em que um dos times tenta provocar a expulsão de um jogador da equipe adversária.

“Você tem os 11 jogadores. Evidentemente, a gente tem posições diferentes, cada um tem a sua estratégia. Faz parte do jogo. Mas quando um dos times passa a trabalhar para que puxem jogadores do outro time, você deixou de jogar e não quer deixar que o outro time jogue, portanto”, disse o ministro.

Para Barroso, trabalhar pela destituição de um ministro do STF é um “elemento não desejável do debate público”. Por outro lado, ele observou que, em uma democracia, nenhum assunto deve ser tratado como tabu, nem mesmo o debate sobre a anistia para os condenados pelos ataques de 8 de janeiro de 2023.

No dia 9 de setembro, parlamentares de oposição entregarem ao presidente do Senado, Rodrigo Pacheco (PSD-MG), um pedido de impeachment do ministro Alexandre do Moraes — que é relator na corte de inquéritos sobre fake news e milícias digitais, além de diversas investigações sobre os atos golpistas de 8 de janeiro.

Crivo da corte

Na entrevista, Barroso afirmou que encara com naturalidade as discussões sobre a definição de mandato para ministro do STF e limites para decisões monocráticas. Ele destacou, porém, que ainda que tais propostas sejam aprovadas no Congresso, o STF tem a prerrogativa de revertê-las.

“O Supremo tem um papel de interpretar e aplicar a Constituição. Pode ser, sim, aferido em face da Constituição, se o Supremo achar que é constitucional o ato. (Mas) se o Supremo achar que é inconstitucional, o ato não vale. É uma coisa também que muitas vezes as pessoas não entendem”, disse ele.

#ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm { width: 600px; margin: 0 auto !important; border-style: ridge; border-color: #0C6291; border-radius: 0; border-width: 2px; box-shadow: none;background-color: #FBFEF9; background-position: center center; background-repeat: no-repeat; background-size: cover; max-width: 100%; position: relative; padding-bottom: 60px; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing{ display: flex; align-items: center; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 div.ays-image-logo-show{ position: absolute; bottom: -5px; left: 1px; margin: 2px 0 0 0; padding: 2px; width: 100%; height: 65px; text-align: left; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .ays-poll-image-logo{ width: 55px; height: 55px; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing input[type=radio]:checked + label, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing label.ays_enable_hover:hover{ background-color: #0C6291 !important; color: #0C6291 !important; border-color: #0C6291 !important; font-weight: initial !important; margin:3px 0 !important; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing input[type=radio]:checked + label *, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing input[type=checkbox]:checked + label *, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing label.ays_enable_hover:hover *{ color: #0C6291; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing input[type=radio]{ border-radius: 50%; width: 20px; height: 19px; margin: 3px !important; border: 1px solid #1e8cbe; opacity: 1; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-answers .apm-choosing input[type=radio]:checked::after{ content: ”; border-radius: 50%; width: 11px; height: 11px; background-color: #1e8cbe; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing input[type=radio]:focus{ outline-offset: 0 !important; outline: unset !important; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing label{ border-color: #0C6291 !important; font-weight: initial !important; margin:3px 0 !important; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .apm-choosing input[type=’radio’]{ display: block !important; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme input[type=’button’].ays-poll-btn:hover, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme input[type=’button’].ays-poll-btn:focus{ text-decoration: none; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme input[type=’button’].ays-poll-btn{ color: initial !important; background: initial !important; border: 1px solid #0C6291; border-radius: 3px; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .ays_poll_passed_count{ color: #0C6291 !important; background: initial !important; border: 1px solid #0C6291; border-radius: 3px; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .ays_poll_passed_count i.ays_poll_fa:before{ color: #0C6291 !important; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.ays-minimal-theme .answer-percent{ color: initial !important; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm span.ays_poll_passed_count{ background-color: #0C6291; color: #FBFEF9; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm span.ays_poll_passed_count i{ color: #FBFEF9; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-title-box{ background-color: rgba(255,255,255,0); } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .answer-percent { background-color: #0C6291; color: #FBFEF9 !important; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .ays-poll-btn{ color: #FBFEF9 !important; background-color: #0C6291 !important; overflow: hidden; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .ays-poll-view-more-button{ border-radius: 0; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm * { color: #0C6291; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-title-box div { color: #0C6291; text-transform: inherit; font-family: inherit; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm i { color: #0C6291; font-size: 24px; font-style: normal; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .ays-poll-btn{ width: auto; font-size: 17px; padding: 10px 20px; border-radius: 3px; color: #FBFEF9 !important; background: #0C6291 !important; border: none; line-height: 12px !important; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .apm-add-answer input.ays-poll-new-answer-apply-text{ width: 100%; margin-bottom: 0; margin-right: 5px; border-color: #0C6291; padding: 7px; font-size: 14px; color: black; height: 40px; outline: none; display: inline-block; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm i.ays_poll_far{ font-family: ‘Font Awesome 5 Free’; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-each-answer-list{ width: initial; text-align: initial; display: initial; padding: 10px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-each-answer-grid{ width: 100%; text-align: left; display: inline-block; word-break: break-word; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays_label_poll{ width: 100%; text-align: center; display: flex; ; align-items: center; padding: 10px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-each-image{ height: 150px; border-radius: 0px; object-fit: cover; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-each-image-list{ width: 220px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-each-image-grid{ width: 100%; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-answer-container-label-grid{ align-items: center; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-answer-container-label-list{ flex-direction: row; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays_poll_grid_view_container{ display: flex; flex-wrap: wrap; justify-content: space-between; align-items: flex-start; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-answer-container-gird{ width: calc(50% – 5px); margin-bottom: 10px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays_poll_label_without_padding{ padding: 10px; align-items: center; flex-direction: column; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-title-box div{ font-size: 20px; word-break: break-word; word-wrap: break-word; text-align: center; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-answer-container-list{ margin-bottom: 10px; display: flex; width: 100%; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-maker-text-answer-main input, #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-maker-text-answer-main textarea{ min-width: 150px; max-width: 100%; width: %; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-password-box .ays-poll-password-button-box .ays-poll-password-button{ background-color: #0C6291; color: #FBFEF9; border-color: #0C6291; outline: none; box-shadow: unset; border: 0; transition: .5s; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-password-box .ays-poll-password-button-box .ays-poll-password-button:hover{ background-color: #0C6291b5; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-password-box .ays-poll-password-input-box .ays-poll-password-input{ border-color: #0C6291; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-answers .apm-choosing label.ays_label_poll{ box-shadow:unset; border-radius: 0px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm.text-poll .apm-answers .ays-poll-text-types-inputs{ font-size: 16px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 div.apm-load-message-container{ background-color: #FBFEF9 !important; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.choosing-poll label { background-color: #FBFEF9; border: 1px solid #0C6291; text-transform: inherit; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.choosing-poll input[type=radio]:checked + label, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970:not(.ays-minimal-theme).choosing-poll input[type=’checkbox’]:checked + label, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.choosing-poll label.ays_enable_hover:hover { background-color: #0C6291 !important; color: #FBFEF9; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970:not(.ays-minimal-theme).choosing-poll input[type=’checkbox’]{ display: none; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.choosing-poll input[type=radio]:checked + label *, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.choosing-poll input[type=checkbox]:checked + label *, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.choosing-poll label.ays_enable_hover:hover * { color: #FBFEF9; }.ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .apm-info-form input { border-color: #0C6291; } div[class~=ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970] label.ays_label_font_size { font-size: 16px; } button.ays-poll-next-btn:focus { background: unset; outline: none; } button.ays-poll-next-btn:disabled { cursor: not-allowed; background: dimgrey !important; color: white !important; } button.ays-poll-next-btn:enabled { cursor: pointer; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .apm-info-form input { color: #0C6291 !important; background-color: #FBFEF9 !important; } .ays-poll-main #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .ays-poll-img { object-fit: cover; height: 100%; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 div.apm-loading-gif .apm-loader svg path, .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 div.apm-loading-gif .apm-loader svg rect { fill: #0C6291; }.ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 div.apm-loading-gif .apm-loader{ display: flex; justify-content: center; align-items: center; padding-top: 10px; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 div.apm-loading-gif{ width: 100%; height: 100%; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays_question p{ font-size: 16px; } @media only screen and (max-width: 768px){ #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm { width: 100%; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-btn{ width: auto; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays_question p{ font-size: 16px; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .apm-answers .apm-rating i.ays_poll_fa-star { font-size: 4vw !important; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .ays-poll-answer-container-gird{ width: 100%; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-title-box div{ font-size: 20px; text-align: center; word-break: break-word; word-wrap: break-word; } .ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm label.ays_label_font_size { font-size: 16px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm.text-poll .apm-answers .ays-poll-text-types-inputs{ font-size: 16px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-answers > .apm-choosing > .ays_label_poll > div.ays-poll-answer-image > img.ays-poll-each-image{ height: 150px; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-answers .apm-choosing > label.ays-poll-answer-container-label-list > p.ays-poll-answers > span.ays-poll-each-answer-list { padding: unset; word-wrap: break-word; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970 .ays-poll-btn{ font-size: 17px; line-height: 1; white-space: normal; word-break: break-word; } } @media screen and (max-width: 768px){ #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970{ max-width: 100%; } } #ays-poll-container-6{ width: 600px; } @media screen and (max-width: 768px){ #ays-poll-container-6{ width: 100%; max-width: 96%; } #ays-poll-id-6a21da489f970.box-apm .apm-choosing .ays-poll-each-image-list{ width: 100%; } } var dataCss = { width: ‘600px’, maxWidth: ‘98%’, fontSize: ’16px’, padding: ’10px’, margin: ‘0 auto’, marginTop: ‘-1rem’, borderStyle: ‘ridge’, borderWidth: ‘2px’, borderColor: ‘#0C6291’, background: ‘#FBFEF9’, color: ‘#0C6291’, transition: ‘.3s ease’, WebkitAppearance: ‘none’, appearance: ‘none’, }; var hoverCss = { background: ‘#0C6291’, color: ‘#FBFEF9’, borderColor: ‘#FBFEF9’, };